HOMEMADE CURDLED MILK

Posted on: May 24, 2020. Updated on: July 12, 2023.

by Carolina Gelen

Can you relate to that moment when you have to much milk hanging around for some reason in your fridge, and it’s too close to its expiration date for you and your family to consume it in time?

I got you! It’s time to stop wasting those gallons of milk and make some delicious cheese out of it, yes, cheese! All you have to do it keep it at room temperature for a few days, and, boom, you’ve got yourself some luscious cheese curds starting to form.

I remember having this as a child at my grandparents house, they would always make this and serve it in many forms, from buttermilk to a hard cuttable cheese.

INGREDIENTS

FOR REFERENCE, 1 LITER OF MILK WILL YIELD 300-350 GRAMS OF CHEESE
FOR THE CHEESE:
  • whole milk
FOR SERVING (350 grams of cheese):
  • 1/2 to 1 teaspoon salt
  • 1/4 cup extra virgin olive oil
  • freshly cracked black pepper
  • fresh basil leaves
  • chives or scallions
  • Za’atar

INSTRUCTIONS

Step 1

Dump all of your milk in a large jar (or any container really) and cover it with a cheesecloth (or a towel, poked saran wrap, or just loosely place its lid on top. Keep the milk at room temperature, anywhere in the kitchen!

The whole idea is that you do not want to place it in an air tight container, you want the air to be able to penetrate the milk, starting the fermentation of it.

First day
Last day

Make sure your sound is on while watching this video:

Step 2

I can’t give you the exact number of days it will take for your milk to ferment, you will be able to tell that by simply looking at it and tasting it.

During the first couple of days, the milk will be in the kefir/buttermilk stage, then, it will start to fully curdle up and become a scoopable cheese. The more you leave it to ferment, the tangier it will become.

There are so many variables that play a role in the fermentation process, making it faster or slower, like: climate, temperature, humidity, the type of milk you are using, how old was the milk before you took it out to ferment (was it close to its expiration date or not?), etc.

Once the fermentation starts happening, the milk solids will start separating from the whey, creating this soft, tangy, curdy cheese floating in the jar. All milk contains bacteria and alive components, which feeds off of the sugars and other substances found in the milk. The compounds generated by that bacteria feeding process changes the pH of our milk, which will cause it to solidify and clump up.

SERVING IDEA

Step 1

Scoop the cheese out of the jar and add it to a clean bowl. If you want the cheese to firm up even more, mix some salt in it, pop it in a cheese cloth and let the liquid strain further away.

Step 2

Mix 1/2 to 1 teaspoon of salt (to taste).

Step 3

Add dollops of your soft cheese onto the serving plate. Drizzle olive oil on top, sprinkle some za’atar, fresh basil leaves, chives, freshly cracked black pepper and some flakey salt.

You can really have fun with it when it comes to toppings, here are some other ways you

could top this (substitute the labneh with your freshly made curdled milk cheese):

SWEET: POMEGRANATE TAHINI DIP

SAVORY: ROSEMARY GARLIC OIL

Serve this with any kind of bread, crackers or a crudité platter.

HOMEMADE CURDLED MILK

3 / 5. from 2

Click to vote

3 / 5. from 2

Click to vote

Ingredients

FOR REFERENCE, 1 LITER OF MILK WILL YIELD 300-350 GRAMS OF CHEESE
FOR THE CHEESE:
  • whole milk
FOR SERVING (350 grams of cheese):
  • 1/2 to 1 teaspoon salt
  • 1/4 cup extra virgin olive oil
  • freshly cracked black pepper
  • fresh basil leaves
  • chives or scallions
  • Za’atar

Instructions

  1. Dump all of your milk in a large jar (or any container really) and cover it with a cheesecloth (or a towel, poked saran wrap, or just loosely place its lid on top. Keep the milk at room temperature, anywhere in the kitchen!

    The whole idea is that you do not want to place it in an air tight container, you want the air to be able to penetrate the milk, starting the fermentation of it.

  2. I can’t give you the exact number of days it will take for your milk to ferment, you will be able to tell that by simply looking at it and tasting it.

    During the first couple of days, the milk will be in the kefir/buttermilk stage, then, it will start to fully curdle up and become a scoopable cheese. The more you leave it to ferment, the tangier it will become.

    There are so many variables that play a role in the fermentation process, making it faster or slower, like: climate, temperature, humidity, the type of milk you are using, how old was the milk before you took it out to ferment (was it close to its expiration date or not?), etc.

    Once the fermentation starts happening, the milk solids will start separating from the whey, creating this soft, tangy, curdy cheese floating in the jar. All milk contains bacteria and alive components, which feeds off of the sugars and other substances found in the milk. The compounds generated by that bacteria feeding process changes the pH of our milk, which will cause it to solidify and clump up.

  3. Scoop the cheese out of the jar and add it to a clean bowl. If you want the cheese to firm up even more, mix some salt in it, pop it in a cheese cloth and let the liquid strain further away.

  4. Mix 1/2 to 1 teaspoon of salt (to taste).
  5. Add dollops of your soft cheese onto the serving plate. Drizzle olive oil on top, sprinkle some za’atar, fresh basil leaves, chives, freshly cracked black pepper and some flakey salt.

Carolina Gelen

You may have seen my work on TV, Food Network, NYT Cooking, Food52 and more. I make recipes more fun and accessible for home cooks. I immigrated to the US from Transylvania, Romania—where I lived most of my life—in 2021 to pursue my passion for cooking full-time. Here you’ll find a collection of approachable recipes, from weeknight dinners to desserts, you’ll come back to over and over again. Some of my most popular recipes include my chicken paprikash, orange chicken roast with fennel and shallots or butter beans all vodka. Some recipes are inspired by my Romanian-Hungarian upbringing, and most definitely all come with that Transylvanian resourcefulness! I love a good thrift, so make sure to catch my thrift hauls every Sunday on my Instagram!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

9 thoughts on "HOMEMADE CURDLED MILK"

  1. Audrey says:

    Hi! It looks great! Can’t wait to try it…
    The jar stays in the refrigerator or on the counter?

    1. Carolina Gelen says:

      I’m so happy to hear that, Audrey! I just updated the post, you’re right, I forgot to mention that the jar will be kept at room temperature, on the counter.

  2. Susan says:

    Is this safe to do with Raw milk?

    1. Carolina Gelen says:

      I would suggest boiling the raw milk first in order to pasteurize it and kill the bacteria in it. Raw milk can carry dangerous germs which can pose serious health risks 🙂

  3. Justine says:

    Can’t wait to try this out! Have you ever tried it with buttermilk? Think it would work the same? I always have leftover buttermilk so this would be a great use for it (I hope). Thanks!

  4. WWW.XMC.PL says:

    Your responsibility is your response to His ability.

  5. Eduardo Hernandez says:

    looks great ¡ what about the liquid once the solids separate ‘ something to do with it ? delicious recipes always ¡ so diverse , traditional and new at the same time ¡ astar on the raise ¡ Thank you Carolina

    1. Carolina says:

      You can add a bit of liquid in pancake batter for a touch of tanginess, otherwise, simply discard it in the sink 🙂 That is such a nice compliment, grateful to have you here, Eduardo!

  6. Judy says:

    Thank you for your post! I was looking for a cheese recipe that didn’t include heating the milk in a pan. I bought goat milk and then forgot to bring it in from the car. Needless to say, I now have some beautifully curdling milk on my hands, and I’m wanting to make cheese without destroying the natural enzymes in it.